Invite a friend!

Old Mill Inn

Address
5775 W Mill Rd Mattituck NY 11952
Phone
(631) 298-8080
theoldmillinn.net
Is this your business?
Claim it now!
Something wrong?
Submit a correction
Average Rating
4.5
Total Reviews
(35)
Leave a review with:
  1. 1 Star
  2. 2 Stars
  3. 3 Stars
  4. 4 Stars
  5. 5 Stars
Is this your business? Claim it now!
Get Directions

Share on
Share

Contact Us

Business Hours

Status: Closed

Sunday
12:00pm-9:00pm
Monday
12:00pm-9:00pm
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
12:00pm-9:00pm
Thursday
12:00pm-9:00pm
Friday
12:00pm-10:00pm
Saturday
12:00pm-10:00pm

Additional Info

YellowBot Recommends

Ramada Inn

  • 1830 W Main St Riverhead, NY 11901
  • (631) 369-2200

View Profile

Madison Health Foods

  • 59 Wall St Madison, CT 06443
  • (203) 245-8607

View Profile

Submit a correction

Know more about this business than we do? Cool! Please submit any corrections or missing details you may have.

Help us make it right

What the community has to say about Old Mill Inn

Information about this business (2)

Under new management!

Fresh Seafood, Modern American Cuisine with Emphasis on Local Produce, and the Best Waterfront Dining

"It's a comfortable, elegant and a genuine place with fantastic food. It's a place I will go to again and again."—Dan's Pape...rs "It remains to this day ever so slightly under the radar, easily accessible by boat for lunch, and worth going the extra two miles by car for a comfortable atmosphere and serious food experience."—East End Buzz.com Welcome to the historic Old Mill Inn, a former...

Add Photo or Video
User Photos & Videos

Be the first YellowBot user to add photos or videos of Old Mill Inn

Reviews of this business (91) view all

Share a review

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Top 3 sentiment words

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Rating distribution

5 stars
21
4 stars
5
3 stars
3
2 stars
1
1 star
2
No rating
59
See more reputation details

Other reviews from the web (91) view all

Average Rating
80

my wife and I love going to the Old Mill. The ambiance is warm and inviting. The pub with its weekend entertainment is always popping and some interesting characters populate it. The beach bar in the afternoon has a great scene and lovely view. The clams and oysters always fresh. As for dinning, the meals are usually well prepared but...

Delicious lunch w/fantastic views of Mattituck inlet

Average Rating
100

Went to lunch here yesterday w/2 girlfriends & we were not disappointed. One of us had a terrific butternut squash soup & 2 of us had the crabcake sandwich w/homemade scallop shaped chips. It was delicious. The view was also to die for on a blustery Sunday afternoon. Nice & cozy inside!

Business description (2)

Old Mill Inn can be found at W Mill Rd 5775. The following is offered: Restaurants. The entry is present with us since Sep 9, 2010 and was last updated on Nov 14, 2013. In Mattituck there are 6 other Restaurants. An overview can be found here.

Need a mini vacation? Check out this unspoiled corner of Long Island. Sit back and relax at The Old Mill Inn, your waterfront getaway since 1821.

© 2007-2018 Solfo, Inc. – All rights reserved