Invite a friend!

Il Compare

Address
34 Old State Rte 22 Wingdale NY 12594
Phone
(845) 832-3411
Is this your business?
Claim it now!
Something wrong?
Submit a correction
Average Rating
4
Total Reviews
(25)
Leave a review with:
  1. 1 Star
  2. 2 Stars
  3. 3 Stars
  4. 4 Stars
  5. 5 Stars
Is this your business? Claim it now!
Share on
Share

Business Hours

Status: Open

Sunday
Closed
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
Closed
Thursday
5:00pm-10:00pm
Friday
5:00pm-10:00pm
Saturday
5:00pm-10:00pm

Additional Info

Submit a correction

Know more about this business than we do? Cool! Please submit any corrections or missing details you may have.

Help us make it right

What the community has to say about Il Compare

Reviews of this business (26) view all

Share a review

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Top 3 sentiment words

Overall review sentiment

Score
%

Rating distribution

5 stars
15
4 stars
4
3 stars
4
2 stars
1
1 star
1
No rating
1
See more reputation details

Other reviews from the web (26) view all

Good food, so-so service

Average Rating
60

We were there for Sunday brunch. The food is good. The atmosphere is good. The owner is very nice. The prices are totally reasonable. Unfortunately, the service needs improvement. Our server admitted it was her second day there, and although she was very nice, she really needed more training. The kitchen service is lacking in that we were the first...

Lousy Service

Average Rating
20

Good location near route 22... a few minutes from the Wingdale train station. The server that I had told me that he was high on drugs and I believed him. I approached the owner of the restaurant and he did not seem to care at all. He also does catering for Pawling Country Club which is a complete shock. Whoever...

good food, bad service

Average Rating
60

We were impressed with the food, but the service left a lot to be desired. We waited a very long time for our waiter to take our order, and then a very long time before the food came. It seemed like they were more interested in the "regulars" than satisfying a new customer.

I can see the change

Average Rating
60

We used to be regulars before the new ownership but now we go very infrequently. It used to be like family and all about generosity; oversized drinks, complimentary bruschetta and olives, plenty of bread , etc. The new ownership has a high turnover of personnel so the familiar feeling is gone. They also have a more spartan approach, not so...

Pleasantly surprised

Average Rating
100

Everything we ordered was presented beautifully and prepared perfectly....I'm thrilled this i wonderful restaurant so close to home!

© 2007-2026 Solfo, Inc. – All rights reserved