http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html http://st1.ypbot.net/ypprod/brands/yellowbot/logo_homepage_header.v0aa1e17.gif http://www.yellowbot.com/ http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Seafood never is fresh.....alway's has stale /frozen taste. Beer is alway's semi warm,,,gross tiny bathroom http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html I love Gillys! Great staff, so friendly. You can ask them to modify menu-no problem. Highly recommend http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Gillys rocks! Great local casual place. Super nice people and comfort food. Love this place! http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html loved it all. half price appetizers always awesome. great service lovely surroundings easy parking very italian flair http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html If you are not over the age of 75 you'll likely not be welcome here. Forget about bringing kids to this "family" restaurant. They are shunned and you will be demeaned out loud by the waitstaff. I brought my kid there once. he was well behaved but at 20 months old he was talking "loud." next think I know the... http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Live a few towns away, been eating here for 20+ years. Can never go too long without getting my Gilly's "fix". Great friendly staff, perfect beverages, excellent tasty food, awesome atmosphere and decor. Try the buffalo wings, they are fantastic.. actually, everything on menu is! I highly recommend Gilly's for a great time. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Price atmosphere food and location were all great.... but sit at a table the booths are not good at all if someone is sitting behind you. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html My husband and I were trying to find a place to eat at last minute on St. Patty's Day. Most of the restaurants we tried were too jam-packed, so I don't know what that says about Gilly's that they had room to accommodate us without reservations. There were quite a few senior citizens dining in there when we first walked... http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html We decided to finally try this local restaurant. We went on a Friday night and it wasn't very busy. We thought it was pub food related, but the menu has a more upscale diner motif. The waitress was very attentive and pleasant. Everything was brought in a timely manner and the food prepared nicely. Simple is best. We will return. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Nice atmosphere, good food, plenty of choices and reasonably priced. Tasty daily specials too. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html The variety of items on the menu was awesome and I had some of the best appetizers I have had ANYWHERE! The duck and arugula or the roasted peppers with fresh mozzarella....what to choose? Both were excellent. My pasta with vodka sauce was tasty.....my steak was cooked to perfection......and the veal parm was the best I have ever had. The... http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html The other day, I was there with my wife, the service was slow, rude, and the food was terrible. I not recommend this restaurant to anyone. Eat local yes, just not here. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Surprisingly my wife and I had never tired this place before. Living only a few blocks away we've drove by a hundred times. We came in lured by their 12.99 lobster special. Sound like a deal? Trust me it wasn't! I ordered the lobster and my wife tried the duck special and we split the exotic sounding Portuguese muscle appetizer.... http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Pleasant, friendly local atmosphere and the staff was very friendly. There is a quaint little bar area as you enter. The apps were excellent as my calamari was cooked perfectly (sounds easy but actually hard to do right). For my entree, I ordered one of Gilly's signature dishes which is basically as Zuppa di Pesce. The mussels were tough and rubbery, so I have to assume not fresh and the sauce was a bit generic and lacked any outstanding seasoning. My wife ordered a stuffed fish which was also a little bland. Dessert and coffee was on the money. For 2 people sharing an app we easily hit the $100 price range for what i would consider a $60 meal, so I am on the fence as to if I would return. 3 out of 5 stars. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Middle-aged man's watering hole and family seafood restaurant. I feel slightly bad because they do tout their seafood and I haven't sampled any of it. However, I have eaten here several times and… http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html The food was good the service was so so. We sat there for a good 15 minutes with the waitress ignoring us. Another couple was seated,given drinks and we asked the bus boy where our waitress was. She told us we didnt say anything???? Last time I checked when you see no one going to a tabl the waitress is supposed to say something?? After that though things were fine and the food was hot and good. Maybe on a less busy night the service is better. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Good, average pub fare, but at a premium price. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html I recently move to Wayne, NJ and found Gilly's Restaurant which is located in Pompton Plains about 5 minutes from where I live. The place is cozy and friendly. The food was excellent and so was the service. We had seafood and my son had steak. We had an enjoyable evening and would recommend Gilly's to our friends and family. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html The ambience is very warm and inviting. The food is very tasty and always fresh. The portions are very generous and the prices are very affordable. This is my favorite of all in northern New Jersey, without a doubt. http://www.yellowbot.com/gillys-restaurant-pompton-plains-nj.html Food was pretty good, but was unhappy with the wine list. Ordered a bottle that was advertised in the menu as a Cabernet Sauvignon and the bottle was brought to the table already opened! Waitress argued with me when I told her it should be opened at the table, even after I explained why. I reluctantly accepted the wine (my wife was getting embarrassed) but then discovered it was Claret, which is a mix of five varietals of wines, the dominant one a Cabernet. It tasted more like a Merlot. It was definitely a downer on what should have been a good occasion - my wife and my 39th valentines together. Oh well. I won't be back here. Find local businesses and read and submit reviews and ratings q http://www.yellowbot.com/search