Paul's Live From New York Pizza

Average Rating

60

We had the combo pizza and it was good and the pizza was freshly cooked but I hate a pizza that when it comes out of the oven it already looks like it's been sitting for to long. You get that slick layer of solid cheese instead of the fresh look to where you go to grab a slice the...

Posted by Paul W on March 01, 2015. Brought to you by tripadvisor.

Average Rating

80

As an East Coast transplant, I was pleasantly surprised by the awesomeness of this pizza place and continued to enjoy it for years. But lately, I've been...

Posted by Robin Z. on February 09, 2015. Brought to you by menupix.

Average Rating

100

Ok, I have eaten a lot of pizza over the years... by the piece and by the pie. I LOVE coming to Eureka and having pizza at Paul's. This is as good as it gets. I was brought her by friends for dinner. Since then, I have returned solo and with friends.
The atmosphere is basic diner style, the customer...

Posted by TheDocIsOut on January 24, 2015. Brought to you by tripadvisor.

Average Rating

100

Saw this place on Triple D and decided to stop here on our trip home from Oregon. SO WORTH IT! As seen on TV and then some. Best pie I've had in years. Staff was friendly and attentive. Took it back to our room and polished it off. I'll dream about this pie.

Posted by Kathryn R on October 07, 2014. Brought to you by tripadvisor.

Average Rating

100

After a five minute chat with our waiter, what a nice guy, we ordered our carry out pizza with all those fresh ingredients, and waited. About 30 minutes later we had our pizza and we're back at the room. There was no talking for the next 25 minutes, just the sound of eating a fabulous, delicious, thin crust pizza. Saw...

Posted by George D on October 05, 2014. Brought to you by tripadvisor.

A local family owned pizza company with three locations Mckinleyville CA, Arcata CA and Eureka CA

Posted on October 12, 2014. Brought to you by facebook.

Paul's Live From New York Pizza is located at 604 F St, Eureka, CA. This business specializes in Pizza.

Posted on November 24, 2013. Brought to you by merchantcircle.