Authentic Italian cuisine in the South Street Seaport Historic District Authentic Italian in Manhattan Casual, friendly, romantic Oldest neighborhood This is probably the best authentic Italian restaurant in New York City with superb food, friendly atmosphere and nice decor. Try the Tagliata steak or the mezzi rigati pasta with shrimps and baby artichokes. The wine list offers a great selection of Italian wines from boutique wineries at very reasonable price. The bar scene is lively and sparkling, like the perfectly executed "Bellini" they serve. It's one of the best kept secrets in Lower Manhattan.